Dune: science fiction’s reply to Lord of the Rings – The Guardian

Dune: science fiction’s reply to Lord of the Rings – The Guardian


Frank Herbert’s novel, now tailored for cinema with Timothée Chalamet and Zendaya, is lastly getting the popularity it deserves, agree authors together with Neil Gaiman and Jeff VanderMeer

Mon 18 Oct 2021 08.34 BST

If science fiction has a solution to fantasy’s The Lord of the Rings – JRR Tolkien’s epic saga of the battle to defeat the Darkish Lord, Sauron – then Frank Herbert’s Dune needs to be a powerful contender. Printed in 1965, it’s the story of the desert planet Arrakis, often called Dune; of the uncommon and priceless “spice” that may be discovered there; of the Atreides household, despatched to Dune’s harmful floor to rule; of its native Fremen individuals, who’re able to surviving on this inhospitable surroundings. Of the enormous sandworms, tons of of metres lengthy, which hunt beneath the sands, and of Paul Atreides’ reluctant ascent to messianic standing. And it’s lastly getting the mainstream consideration it deserves, due to Denis Villeneuve’s movie adaptation, out within the UK on 21 October.

I first learn Dune once I was 18. It left behind deep, haunting reminiscences: Paul Atreides chanting the Litany towards Concern as his humanity is examined by the Gom Jabbar; the primary look of a sandworm, huge and luxurious; the complexity of Paul’s rise to turn into the Bene Gesserit’s Kwisatz Haderach, the Fremen’s Mahdi (like a lot of the Fremen’s tradition, the phrase is lifted from the vocabulary of Islam). As one character places it: “No extra horrible catastrophe may befall your individuals than for them to fall into the palms of a Hero.”

Director Denis Villeneuve, whose adaptation hits cinemas later this month – is the fourth try, after Alejandro Jodorowsky’s plans got here to nothing, David Lynch disowned his 1984 model starring Kyle MacLachlan and Sting, and a tv miniseries. “There are deep pleasures when there are pictures that you just’re capable of obtain which are near what you had in thoughts as an adolescent,” Villeneuve has stated.

Frank Herbert. Photograph: Ulf Andersen/Getty Photos

“I learn it the primary time once I was 11 or so,” says Kevin Anderson, the bestselling writer who, along with Herbert’s son Brian, has continued the Dune collection after his father’s dying. “I had learn all of HG Wells and Edgar Rice Burroughs and Andre Norton and Ray Bradbury and all these nice traditional science fiction books, however Dune is one thing above and past these. Once I learn it, I simply felt so immersed on the planet that every part felt actual. He had provide you with not only a desert planet with sandworms, he had the complete ecology labored out, the entire tradition, even the language and the faith of the individuals and the enormous galactic politics and the way there are wheels inside wheels and every part suits collectively.”

Herbert’s first inspiration for Dune got here in 1957, when he went to analysis a magazine article a couple of analysis undertaking in Oregon to stabilise sand dunes. The article, They Stopped the Shifting Sands, was by no means revealed, however a letter he despatched to his agent, revealed in The Street to Dune, exhibits how fascinated he was: “Sand dunes pushed by regular winds construct up in waves analogous to ocean waves besides they might transfer 20 ft a yr as a substitute of 20 ft a second. These waves might be each bit as devastating as a tidal wive in property harm … and so they’ve even prompted deaths. They drown out forests, kill sport cowl, destroy lakes, fill harbours.”

Herbert would toy with the thought of a desert planet for the following 5 years, spending time in a desert as a part of his analysis, plotting a brief journey novel, Spice Planet, however placing it apart for what would turn into Dune. He despatched an early draft to his agent in 1963, and the story was revealed in serial type in John W Campbell’s Analog journal that yr. It was rejected by publishers greater than 20 occasions in e book type, one citing “bursts of melodrama”, one other that “no person can appear to get by the primary 100 pages … with out being confused and irritated”. A remark from one rejecting editor, that “it’s simply doable that we could also be making the error of the last decade in declining Dune by Frank Herbert”, would show as prophetic as considered one of Paul’s personal visions, as would one other’s comment that he would flip it down even if “it’s the kind of writing which may appeal to a cult and go on for ever”.

“For good or unwell, Frank wrote a e book that was on the time unpublishable. When you’re a enterprise individual advising Frank, you’ll say don’t write Dune, no person will publish this e book this lengthy, with this a lot tradition and background,” says Anderson. “However we’re glad that he didn’t take heed to anyone, he simply wrote his personal e book and it’s definitely one of many biggest science fiction novels of all time.”

In the long run, Chilton Books, higher identified for auto restore manuals, picked it up in 1965. It received a Nebula for the perfect science fiction novel of 1965, however gross sales weren’t stellar at first, regardless of the quote from Arthur C Clarke emblazoned on its cowl: “I do know nothing akin to it besides The Lord of the Rings.”

“It wasn’t perceived as an on the spot traditional; publishers noticed this massive e book on ecological themes as slightly peculiar, a kind of Lawrence of Arabia within the stars,” says American Gods writer Neil Gaiman. “It labored but it surely hit slowly – it wasn’t like [Robert Heinlein’s 1961 novel] Stranger in a Unusual Land, which got here out and caught hearth, was totally of its zeitgeist. In numerous methods the issues that took Dune into the zeitgeist have been 70s issues, the understanding of and keenness for ecology, the thought of individuals’s place on the planet.”

By 1967, gross sales have been choosing up, and Herbert was engaged on a sequel by 1968. Dune Messiah would see Paul as emperor, presiding over a bloody jihad by the celebrities that ultimately kills 60 billion individuals.


Gaiman describes science fiction as “a dialog with the final spherical of what went earlier than”. What Herbert delivered to the dialog was ecology – in addition to what Gaiman calls “large multigenerational cleaning soap opera”.

“I’d say there’s Dune DNA in Recreation of Thrones, within the willingness to kill your characters, that feeling of the grand sweep of realpolitik and the way it impacts human beings”, says Gaiman.

Jeff VanderMeer agrees. “It undoubtedly has been very influential, and I feel there’s one thing very surreal concerning the navigators and the way in which the Mud is used, after which absolutely the spectacle of the sandworms, whether or not it makes any ecological sense or not. That form of factor actually sticks with you on a large canvas.”

Aspect notice: in keeping with Brian Herbert’s biography of his father, Dreamer of Dune, when Frank noticed Star Wars he “picked out 16 factors of what he known as ‘absolute id’ between his e book and the film, sufficient to make him furious”. Along with different science fiction writers who thought they noticed their work within the movie, Frank fashioned a “free organisation” he known as, “along with his tongue firmly positioned in his cheek, the We’re Too Huge to Sue George Lucas Society”.

Timothée Chalamet and Rebecca Ferguson within the forthcoming Dune movie. Photograph: Chia Bella James/AP

The approaching launch of Villeneuve’s adaption means Dune, and its story of a younger white man main a tribal individuals to victory, is being interrogated afresh. Is it a white saviour narrative? Why are not any Center Japanese or north African actors taking up the roles of the Fremen, given the clear affect of the Arab and Islamic world on Herbert’s creations, asked Syfy? Tutorial Jordan S Carroll describes Dune as “a key textual content for the ‘alt-right’” in the Los Angeles Review of Books, including that “for the alt-right, Paul stands as the perfect of a sovereign ruler who violently overthrows a decadent regime to deliver collectively ‘Europid’ peoples right into a single imperium or ethnostate”.

However as Carroll goes on to level out, that is misreading the purpose of Herbert’s story. “Fascist commentators … overlook that their long-awaited sovereign Paul begins the collection as a tragic character however ends it as a grotesque one,” he writes. Herbert himself said that Dune “started with an idea: to do a protracted novel concerning the messianic convulsions which periodically inflict themselves on human societies”. Removed from revelling in Paul’s immense energy, his thought was, he stated, “that superheroes have been disastrous for people”.

For Hari Kunzru, writing in the Guardian six years ago, “what makes Dune extra palatable than, say, the ugly spectacle of a blonde-wigged Emilia Clarke carried aloft by ethnically indeterminate brown slaves in Recreation of Thrones, is the sincerity of Herbert’s identification with the Fremen”. Arrakis’s individuals, writes Kunzru, are “the ethical centre of the e book, not an ignorant mass to be civilised”, and Paul “doesn’t remodel them in his picture, however participates of their tradition and is himself remodeled into the prophet Muad’Dib”.

On high of this, Paul’s rise, to place it mildly, isn’t any optimistic factor, and Villeneuve, asked about the white saviour trope on his press tour for the film release, made this level. “It’s a critique of that. It’s not a celebration of a saviour,” he stated. “It’s a criticism of the thought of a saviour, of somebody that can come and inform one other inhabitants be, what to imagine. It’s not a condemnation, however a criticism.”


Herbert would comply with Dune Messiah with Youngsters of Dune, God Emperor of Dune, Heretics of Dune, and Chapterhouse: Dune. “It will get an increasing number of summary. I discovered the second and third to be deeply unusual, stranger than the primary one,” says VanderMeer. Herbert’s ultimate Dune novel was revealed in 1985; he died of pancreatic most cancers in 1986.

“The top of Chapterhouse: Dune is simply this enormous cliffhanger – clearly the story wasn’t over,” says Anderson. “At the back of my thoughts, I kind of all the time assumed that Brian Herbert would decide up the mantle and end the final e book, and after 10 years, I lastly acquired impatient sufficient that I tracked down a contact for him and I wrote a letter and I stated, so are you going to complete the story, as a result of I wish to learn it?”

At this level, Anderson was successful awards for his personal novels and penning bestselling titles set within the Star Wars and X-Information universes. He tentatively recommended to Brian that they may work collectively to proceed the collection.

“My biggest desire would have been for Frank Herbert to be alive and write it himself, clearly. I didn’t hear again from Brian for just a few months – it was only a shot at midnight,” Anderson says. “It turned out he had been asking a bunch of different authors about me, and he known as me up one afternoon out of the blue. It turned clear to him that I wasn’t just a few man who learn Dune as soon as and wished to make a buck off of it – that I used to be actually captivated with working within the Dune universe.”

The pair struck a $3m cope with Bantam for a brand new trilogy of prequels in 1997. “On the time it was the biggest single science fiction e book contract in publishing historical past,” says Anderson. “We’ve counted up one thing like 5m phrases we’ve written collectively, and he’s nonetheless my greatest buddy.”

Whereas titles equivalent to Isaac Asimov’s I, Robotic tales now really feel passé, says writer and critic Lisa Tuttle, the truth that Dune takes place on a “secondary world” prevents it from feeling outdated. “And for the reason that 1980s, science fiction and fantasy has moved into the mainstream,” she says. “There’s a receptive viewers keen to take a look at it – it’s not seen as a specialist, area of interest, nerdy form of factor; even when Dune was fashionable within the 70s it was very a lot a form of slim band of individuals.”

Dune holds up in the present day, says author Alastair Reynolds, when many science fiction novels of its period don’t, partly as a result of Herbert future-proofed it, by setting his story 20,000-odd years forward, after the “Butlerian Jihad” has changed clever machines with human minds.

“What Dune did that was enormous and essential, was give us a stunning, sophisticated factor that felt like a film. It feels grand, it’s blood-stirring,” agrees Gaiman. “It doesn’t really feel prefer it’s been swept away into historical past. It was completely an essential e book, and I feel it’s remained an essential e book.”

• Dune is launched in Australia and the UK on 21 October, and within the US on 22 October







We can be in contact to remind you to contribute. Look out for a message in your inbox in . When you have any questions on contributing, please contact us.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *